The dichotomy of control is the most practical rule that Stoicism left: separate, in any affliction, what depends on you from what does not, and spend all your energy only on the first half.
Epictetus' rule
The person who formulated the idea was Epictetus, a Stoic philosopher from the 1st century after Christ, who was born a slave and died free, and knew well both sides of what "does not depend on us". At the beginning of his manual, the Enchirídio, he writes: "some things depend on us, others don't". Judgment, impulse, desire, aversion, in short, everything that is our work, depends on us. Our body, possession, reputation, position, in short, everything that is not our work, does not depend on us.
Where to invest energy
The practical rule is simple to state and difficult to live by: in the face of any affliction, ask first what is yours (the reaction, the interpretation, the choice) and what is not (other people's opinion, the illness, the loss). Invest all your attention only in the first group. The rest, accept with serenity, not because it doesn't matter, but because insisting on it only multiplies the suffering without changing the result.
It's not indifference, it's focus
It's easy to confuse the dichotomy of control with resignation, a "shrug" to the world. It's the opposite: the Stoic acts with excellence exactly where he has real control, in his own character, in his own response, and for this reason he is able to accept with serenity what is beyond his reach. The question that underpins everything is always the same: does what afflicts me depend on me or not? The answer changes what to do next, and mainly changes what to stop doing.
Readings from Nous
Read the classics in depth
Our list of more than 130 recommended books, commented and organized by theme, so you don't read in the dark.
See recommended readingsFrequently asked questions
What is the dichotomy of control?
It's the rule of the Stoic philosopher Epictetus: in any affliction, separate what depends on you (your judgment, your reaction, your virtue) from what doesn't (other people's opinion, illness, death), and invest all your energy only in the first half.
Who created the dichotomy of control?
The Stoic Epictetus, in the 1st century after Christ, summarized the idea at the beginning of his manual, the Enchiridion: "some things depend on us, others do not".
Is the dichotomy of control the same thing as indifference?
No. The Stoic does not stop acting on the world, he acts with excellence exactly where he has real control (his character, his response), and accepts with serenity what is beyond his reach. It's focus, not resignation.
Continue: What is Stoicism · What is the Meaning of Life? · Where does the phrase "who has a reason to live" come from?
Home class (Community NousCast): O Sentido da Vida: o que Camus, Dostoiévski e Frankl responderam