Caravaggio did not paint the theme of David and Goliath just once. He returned to it three times, at different moments in his career, and the differences between the versions alone tell the story of how the painter changed.
Three screens, three museums
The first version, around 1600, is today in the Museo del Prado, in Madrid, painted when Caravaggio was still part of the household of Cardinal Francesco Maria del Monte, at the beginning of his rise in Rome. The second, from 1606-1607, is in the Kunsthistorisches Museum, in Vienna. The third, made between 1605 and 1610 according to the dating adopted by scholars, is in the Galleria Borghese, in Rome, and is the most discussed of the three.
From serenity to confession
The Madrid version has an almost classical serenity, still far from the emotional intensity that would mark the painter's final works. The one in Vienna already shows greater dramatic tension, David being closer to Goliath's gesture and face. But it is Rome's version that carries the greatest weight: the decapitated giant's face is identified as Caravaggio's own self-portrait, painted while he was on the run for murder and seeking a papal pardon.
A topic that became personal investigation
Caravaggio explored certain themes repeatedly throughout his career, as he did with multiple versions of Saint John the Baptist, treating each repetition not as a copy, but as a new emotional and technical investigation. In the case of David and Goliath, this repetition ends in a confession: the last version of the theme is also the most personal, the moment in which the painter placed himself within the work itself.
Readings from Nous
Read the classics in depth
Our list of more than 130 recommended books, commented and organized by theme, so you don't read in the dark.
See recommended readingsFrequently asked questions
How many times did Caravaggio paint the theme of David and Goliath?
Three times, in different museums, the Museo del Prado, in Madrid (around 1600), the Kunsthistorisches Museum, in Vienna (1606-1607), and the Galleria Borghese, in Rome (between 1605 and 1610, according to the dating adopted).
What is the difference between the three versions?
The Madrid version is from the initial phase of his career, more serene. The one in Vienna already shows greater dramatic tension. The one in Rome, the latest, is also the most personal, with Goliath's face identified as a self-portrait of Caravaggio himself.
Why did Caravaggio return to the same biblical theme so many times?
He repeatedly explored certain themes throughout his career, also with multiple versions of Saint John the Baptist, treating each repetition as a new emotional and technical investigation into the same scene.
Continue to the Caravaggio cluster: Who was Caravaggio? · David with the Head of Goliath, by Caravaggio · Galleria Borghese and Caravaggio
Source class (YouTube): Quem foi Caravaggio (NousCast)