The strawman fallacy, known in English as straw man, distorts someone's argument into a weaker version and attacks this caricature, instead of facing what the person actually said.
How the scam works
The name comes from the image of a straw doll: instead of arguing with the real opponent, you put together an easy-to-knock version in his place. "You want to review this law? Then you want chaos." Nobody asked for chaos, they asked for revision, but the exaggerated version is easier to attack than the real proposal.
After knocking down the strawman, whoever used the fallacy acts as if they had won the argument. But the real opponent is still standing, saying exactly what he said before, because the straw doll was never him.
Why is it so common
The strawman is seductive because it requires less effort than responding to the real argument, which is often milder and more difficult to refute. Simplifying the other's position until it becomes an extreme caricature saves you the trouble of facing the strong version of it.
How to identify
The test is simple: ask whether the person supposedly defending that position would recognize the description as fair. If the answer is no, the straw man is in place. The defense against this fallacy, both to recognize it in others and to avoid it in yourself, is always to respond to the strongest version of someone else's argument, never to the weakest.
This fallacy often appears alongside others, such as false dilemma and the ad hominem. They all exploit the same flaw: the difference between appearing to have won the argument and in fact having examined the real argument.
Readings from Nous
Read the classics in depth
Our list of more than 130 recommended books, commented and organized by theme, so you don't read in the dark.
See recommended readingsFrequently asked questions
What is the strawman fallacy?
It's distorting someone's argument into a weaker version, a caricature, and attacking that distorted version instead of the real argument. Also called straw man.
Why is it called "scarecrow" or "straw man"?
Because the attack knocks down an easy-to-defeat straw doll, set up in place of the true argument, which continues to stand, intact, without having actually been faced.
What is an example of a strawman?
"You want to review this law? Then you want chaos." The phrase distorts a specific request for review into an extreme position that no one defended, and attacks this invented version.
The other cluster fallacies: What is ad hominem · What is false dilemma · What is appeal to the majority
Home class (Training in Philosophy and Theology): Ferramentas do Pensamento Crítico